Katie Lannan, “House and Senate no longer singing the same tune on their rules as lawmakers embark on review,” MASSterlist, November 17, 2026.
A year and a half ago, the House and Senate struck a harmonious note as they did something they hadn’t managed since 2019: agreeing to a set of shared internal rules governing their lawmaking.
“At a time when the strength of our institutions matters more than ever, these changes underscore our commitment to serving with unity,” majority leaders Sen. Cindy Creem and Rep. Michael Moran said in a joint statement at the time. Moran would later say the rules deal “will hopefully reduce the legislative logjam of the past” while boosting accountability and civic participation.
After two sessions where the House and Senate could never agree on the joint rules they typically adopt biennially, leaving the 2019 version in place for six years, the accord marked an optimistic milestone. Fast-forward and there’s a bit more discord, plus plenty of signs that logjam is more resilient than anyone expected.
The new rules required more notice for committee hearings, changed deadlines for committees to advance or kill bills, required plain-language bill summaries, and newly called for both written testimony and individual lawmakers’ votes within committees to be available to the public.
The marquee change was the erosion of the traditional July 31 deadline for passing major bills, allowing lawmakers to keep negotiations going and strike deals later in the year. At least in theory.
So far, the House and Senate have yet to reach agreement on any of the 12 bills that were in conference as of July 31.
The stalemate irked Senate President Karen Spilka enough that she told CommonWealth Beacon she couldn’t support a deadline extension again next year unless bills start moving “soon.”
But House Speaker Ron Mariano has a rosier view. He’s repeatedly said it’s the finished product and not the timeline that matters. Asked last month how he thought the new rules are working out, he pointed back to the disastrous 2024 all-nighter that was an impetus for reform. Without a repeat this July, he said, “everything’s much better.”
Buried near the end of the new rules is a requirement that the House and Senate together “conduct a comprehensive review” of those rules, including a public hearing.
When the gavel drops to open that hearing this afternoon, the tone of the testimony is likely to be more in line with Spilka’s take than Mariano’s — or more critical.
Groups including Act on Mass and Progressive Massachusetts wrote to top lawmakers last week, asking when the hearing would be and flagging “loopholes and shortcomings” in the new operations.
“Committees vary greatly in their compliance with the new rules, committees have been able to run out the clock on legislation without ever taking a vote due to House Rule 27, and significant legislative business has been pushed past the end of formal session — a problem from last session normalized in the new system,” the letter says.
The Beacon Hill Compliance Tracker, a civic technology project from independent engineer Drew Bowler, identified thousands of possible rule violations by the end of July, including missing bill summaries or votes, shorter-notice hearings, and missed reporting deadlines. Bowler’s August report, which acknowledges potential glitches and inaccuracies in its measurements, said it amounts to “neither a vindication nor a condemnation of the transparency rules it adopted.”
Whether you think it’s all much better or old problems have been normalized, if this turns out to be the start of another multi-session standoff, the Legislature of 2031 should have plenty to work through.