šŸŽƒIt’s Trick-or-Treating Day, And These Three Ballot Questions Are Trying to Trick You.šŸŽƒ

Happy Halloween! On the day of trick-or-treating, let’s talk about the ballot questions that are trying to trick you.

Question 3’s backers say that their top-two primary question is about promoting competition, openness, and accountability, but in reality, top-two systems harm grassroots and working-class candidates, empower corporate special interest money, and just create a more expensive version of the status quo. More here on Question 3 and why you should VOTE NO.

Question 5’s backers say that their revenue limit campaign is about “affordability,” but in reality, imposing a stricter revenue cap on the state would make it harder for the state to invest in health care, housing, education, and child care and address what’s at the root cause of the high cost of living. More here on Question 5 and why you should VOTE NO.

Question 8’s backers can often sound as though they are trying to protect our cannabis laws, but in reality, these fraudsters are trying to bring back the drug war and drain vital revenue from the state and municipalities. More here on Question 8 and why you should VOTE NO.

PM in the News: “Ballot Question 3 Seeks to End Single-Party Primaries”

Samuel Ruiz-Macias and Mirei S. Saneyoshi, “Ballot Question 3 Seeks to End Single-Party Primaries,” Harvard Crimson, October 29, 2026.

Jonathan R. Cohn, a policy director for Progressive Massachusetts, which has backed the No on 3 campaign, also said that the all-party primary system risks creating a ā€œlockout effectā€ where one political party is not represented between the two candidates that advance to the general election.

…

Cohn also argued that the gubernatorial provision, which prevents governor and lieutenant governor candidates from running individually, would hinder the chances of grassroots gubernatorial candidates advancing past the primaries.

ā€œIf people don’t think you can win, why would they sign up to be your running mate, right?ā€ Cohn said. ā€œIf you’re a kind of a grassroots or insurgent candidate, you expect to peak later on in that race, and the need to pick a running mate early on is a lot of vetting work.ā€

…

ā€œFor a self-described democracy campaign, it’s jarring that it’s pretty much almost entirely funded by private equity executives from Bain Capital and Berkshire Partners,ā€ Cohn said.

Progressive Mass at 15, a message from Harmony Wu

This October marks the 15th anniversary of Progressive Mass’s launch meeting! We are pleased to share this message from one of our founding members on how it all began and where we go from here.

A message from Harmony Wu

Where we came from / Are we there yet

Progressive Mass at Lasell College in Newton: Hundreds of people in a lecture hall. Name tags, photocopies, breakout rooms, butcher paper. My experience is painted in the sensation of dashing from one room to another table. Excitement and movement.

But did it begin that October in Newton, at Lasell? For me, it began earlier: carpools of strangers meeting at T stations and Dunkin’ Donuts parking lots to knock on doors in New Hampshire. Maybe the Dorchester 2010 Health Care Forum was the beta version; where hundreds organized together for health care reform. The Massachusetts Obama campaign ā€œgrasstopsā€ had built a lively prototype in OFAMA, a self-organized statewide infrastructure, before the national campaign launched Organizing for America.

Many people gave their time and labor to this organization, before it was the organization debuting in 2011.

We’d already had a deep history of meetings on conference calls and email discussions, and a year of Saturday bagels and bloody marys meetings in my living room. How could we make a Thing that held the energy, desire, values, and possibility of progressive power in Massachusetts?

Ā 

Fifteen years is a substantial part of a life—the photos show that—but only a handful of legislative sessions. We’ve had successes, but still have far to go.

In 2011, we set out to build a permanent, statewide grassroots organization that could turn progressive values into political power. A small core group did much of the early work, creating something others could join and showing there was a there there beyond its initial organizers. After Lasell, we had evidence of the need and an audience. Next came the challenge of making a democratic organization effective.

I was politically interested and engaged, but not someone ACTIVE in politics. I wanted an easier entry ramp into the actual stuff of politics. We wanted to make progressive knowledge and labor accessible, whether people wanted to research and organize or find a trusted guide to political issues and elections. We wanted to connect them to work for a fairer economy, better ecological stewardship, institutional justice, and a more perfect, just, equal, and free world.

That raised a question we still face: how do you make room for grassroots participation while setting priorities and acting with purpose? American political culture emphasizes elections, then asks us to trust elected officials to deliver. But policy work is where the rubber meets the road. Political power is built at a human scale—neighbor to neighbor, potluck by potluck—and participation has to fit people’s lives and matter. Who sets priorities, decides what work gets done, and whose interests does it serve?

In 2016, a flood of people suddenly understood that their political voice and work were needed, and new groups sprang up everywhere. I worked my ass off to establish enough grounding to direct that energy toward worthwhile, achievable goals.

I had helped create the entry ramp I’d wanted for myself, just as health and other struggles made my own life more complicated. When progressive power depends on endless unpaid labor, people burn out and we lose their experience, relationships, knowledge, and leadership. We should have nice things: organizations with deep benches, adequate funding, and expertise. When exhausted people leave, their hard-won knowledge, interpersonal, institutional, goes with them.

When our power relies on committed people to supply the labor for free, or assumptions that foundations and ā€œSoros moneyā€ (LOL) will pay for it, we lose power, bottom up directive supplanted by the well-meaning grant terms, and people checking out.

Progressive Mass aspires to be funded primarily by the people whose values it represents and whose political work it exists to support.

If we want Progressive Mass to be answerable to us, it needs to be funded by us. Membership dues are an investment in a shared enterprise. Who provides the money and who makes the decisions are connected; the funding model should reinforce accountability.

We’re not there yet, dear reader, dear member, dear new member (I hope). We’re closer than fifteen years ago, but need more members and individual monthly contributions to fund the staff and resources the work requires.

Grassroots funding is one part of lasting political infrastructure: a deep bench of grasstops leaders, growing grassroots participation, and a strong organizing staff. We need to invest in the people doing the work and remain answerable to the people whose power we exist to build.

Harmony Wu
Member and Co-founder, Progressive Mass

“This is exactly what I was looking for”

“This is exactly what I was looking for.”

“I have that saved on my phone.”

“Thank you so much for this.”

I heard this again and again as I was passing our ballot question endorsement palm cards at a recent community festival.

With 9 statewide ballot questions (as well as some additional local or district-specific ballot questions in some communities), the ballot this year is long. Ballot questions can be confusingly worded and have implications that aren’t fully clear at first reading.

That’s why trusted sources of information are so important. Our endorsement palm cards provide that resource.

Here’s how you can help:

  • Share our endorsement graphic on social media or with your friends. (Facebook, Instagram, BlueSky)
  • Want some copies of our palm card to distribute? Just ask us.
  • Click here for a deep dive on each question so you can talk about them fluently.

In solidarity,
Jonathan Cohn
Policy Director
Progressive Massachusetts

āœ…VOTE YES ON 1 to expand the public records law to cover the Governor and the Legislature. We’re the only state in the country that doesn’t do that already. Let the sunlight in.  āœ…VOTE YES ON 2 to enable public defenders to collectively bargain. Every worker deserves to have a union, and public defenders, who are often overworked and underpaid, should be no exception.   āŒVOTE NO ON 3 to prevent private equity billionaires from rigging our election system in their favor. Top-two primaries empower corporate PACs and self-funders, disadvantage grassroots candidates, and turn MAGA voters into election kingmakers.   āœ…VOTE YES ON 4 to enable voters to register to vote or update their registration on Election Day. No eligible voter should be turned away due to a clerical error, and this reform is one of the most proven ways to increase voter turnout.   āŒVOTE NO ON 5 to protect our state’s ability to invest in health care, transportation, and public education. The rich would get millions in tax rebates, while the rest of us suffer from underfunded public services.   ⚪VOTE how you want on 6. Question 6 fell shy of our endorsement threshold: our members valued land and water conservation, but were worried about the dedication of existing funds as opposed to new ones.   āœ…VOTE YES on 7 to enable more starter homes across the Commonwealth. We have a housing crisis, and large lot size requirements mean fewer homes are able to be built.   āŒVOTE NO on 8 to protect our state’s cannabis laws. We said NO to the war on drugs back in 2016, and we shouldn’t turn back time and destroy local economies.   āœ…VOTE YES ON 9 to protect our state’s landmark gun safety law, which cracked down on ghost guns, banned machine gun conversion devices, and strengthened gun violence data collection.

PM in the News: “Three Ballot Questions that Could Affect the Arts This November”

Kim Córdova, “Three Ballot Questions that Could Affect the Arts This November,” Boston Art Review, October 19, 2026.

“No [on 3]: Jonathan Cohn, the policy director of Progressive Massachusetts, says private equity executives provided 71 percent of the funding for the pro–Question 3 campaign. He argues that running twice raises costs and favors well-funded candidates. He also says the system pressures candidates in crowded fields to drop out early, and lets any group of fifty people get its endorsements printed on the ballot.”

“No [on 5]: Cohn of Progressive Massachusetts cites an estimate from the Massachusetts Budget and Policy Center of about $2 billion in lost revenue per year, just as federal cuts are set to hit next year. He argues this would drain rainy-day reserves and lead to cuts in arts and culture spending, as well as the programs creative workers depend on.”

OPINION: No on Q3 – Jungle Primaries are Bad for Working People’s Interests

Jonathan Cohn, “OPINION: No on Q3 – Jungle Primaries are Bad for Working People’s Interests,” Working Mass, October 19, 2026.

The most dangerous words in the English language are: ā€œwe’re from private equity, and we’re here to help.ā€ 

When private equity swoops in to ā€œhelpā€ a struggling business, that typically means worsening labor conditions and worsening product quality—but increasing the money of those private equity executives. That’s exactly what private equity executives are trying to do with democracy in Massachusetts with this year’s Question 3, making it a place where they can more easily buy candidates and forestall progressive victories at the state and federal level. These donors are seeking to curb the rise of more populist messaging and policy that centers working people rather than the rich and large corporations. The fact that jungle primaries are detrimental to workers’ interests is why labor unions and progressive groups across Massachusetts are united in urging you to vote NO on Question 3. 

Question 3 would change MA’s electoral system to a jungle primary system like California and Washington. Proponents have been saying that this is about democracy, accountability, choice, competition, but a quick look at where the money comes from says otherwise. 

According to campaign finance disclosures, 70% of the money raised for Question 3 comes from private equity, with most of that from Bain Capital or Berkshire Partners. Indeed, just six private equity executives account for half of all the money raised by the campaign. These are overwhelmingly donors to conservative Democrats (like MA’s Jake Auchincloss and Seth Moulton) and Republicans (like Susan Collins and Bill Cassidy) who are friendly to the corporate centrism that the financial industry loves.

These donors have a long history of funding education privatization ballot questions, and not a lot of history caring about democracy. 

What is Q3?

Question 3 makes several noteworthy changes to Massachusetts elections. It’s important to understand the risks of all of them. 

The marquee part of Question 3 is the all-party primary system, often called a jungle primary, in which all candidates run on the same ballot and the top two candidates of any party advance to the general election. More on that in a moment.Ā 

Question 3 also changes how MA elects Lieutenant Governors. Currently, MA has a system with the perhaps inartful moniker of ā€œshotgun marriageā€: Governor and Lt. Governor candidates run separately in the primary, and then are paired together in the general election. Under Question 3, gubernatorial candidates would pick their running mates upon formally filing as a candidate with the Secretary of State. Vetting possible running mates is a major hurdle for grassroots and less institutionally connected candidates, and if people don’t think you can win (grassroots candidates often peak late), why would anyone want to bet a year of their time on your campaign? It’s a very clear way to limit the possibility of who can consider running. 

Question 3 also changes ballot design in Massachusetts. In a bastardized version of fusion voting, it allows multiple minor parties to endorse the same candidate on the ballot. Fusion voting in states like New York strengthens democracy by enabling voters to choose minor parties’ ballot lines and help them to build a base. They earn that ballot line by having actual voters. By contrast, in Massachusetts, you can get minor party status with only 50 people petitioning the secretary of state. With such a low threshold, any slumlord can create a minor party (say, ā€œMassachusetts Housing for Allā€), and start endorsing candidates on the ballot with deceptive names. The SuperPACs that flood your mailboxes in election season have to disclose their donors, but imagine if they can just get their endorsements printed directly on your ballot.

A Warning From California

California’s recent gubernatorial primary should be a warning to anyone thinking about voting YES on Question 3 this November. 

This year, given the diverse Democratic field and narrow Republican field in the gubernatorial race, polling consistently showed that two conservative Republicans would advance to the general election, denying voters real choice. 

Out of fear of such a lockout, the CA Democratic Party started pressuring candidates to drop out of the race, and the two dominant candidates became a self-funding billionaire and the candidate backed by every corporate PAC in the state. Actual policy debate was sidelined, and party elites and big money donors were empowered.

Whenever there is a push for consolidation, those with power, money, and privilege will always claim a right to stay in a race, regardless of whether they have the best ideas (often, they don’t). 

One of the biggest advocates for California’s jungle primary system has been the California Chamber of Commerce. They have touted its ability to help them get more corporate-aligned Democrats elected on the basis of lots of outside special interest money, conservative crossover votes in Democrat vs. Democrat general elections, and the loss of cues through which people typically understand the differences between candidates. And they are right, with the emergence of a new bloc of corporate-backed Democrats more loyal to Uber, Chevron, Meta, and crypto than to any constituencies or values.

That’s not a solution to any problem we have in Massachusetts; it will make the ability to pass policies to help working people even harder.

Getting Diverse, Working-Class Candidates to Run

I have worked for many years to try to recruit more candidates to run for office and support them when they do. When I talk with prospective candidates, the two biggest barriers for them when considering running for office are time and money. Running for office takes up a lot of time. It might require you to take an extended leave from work, or balance a full-time campaign and a full-time job. 

It also costs a lot of money to run for office, and most people don’t start out with a readymade list of high-net-worth donor prospects. 

If we want to see more working people run for office, then we need to find ways to rein in the time and financial burdens of running for office. 

Question 3 makes both of them worse, increasing both the time and money involved in running for office–benefiting incumbents and wealthy candidates for whom neither poses a true obstacle. 

Ranked Choice Voting vs. Jungle Primaries 

Although Massachusetts voters unfortunately rejected Ranked Choice Voting in 2020, there has been a robust and inspiring push on the local level to adopt Ranked Choice Voting on the local level. The push for a top-two primary system takes the wind out of those sails. 

New York City’s mayoral race last year showed us the wide-ranging benefits of ranked choice voting. Zohran Mamdani’s Democratic primary was due to an amazing field operation and a compelling message, for sure, but NYC’s Ranked Choice Voting system was essential to how the campaign played out. 

When voters can pick multiple candidates and register their preferences accordingly, progressive candidates aren’t in a fight to the death: they want each other’s voters to also rank them. We saw that dynamic in 2025’s greatest bromance: the cross-endorsement between Zohran Mamdani and former Comptroller and current Congressman-elect Brad Lander and the positivity and goodwill surrounding it. When progressive candidates lift each other up, the ideas and the movement benefit. 

In a ranked choice system, voters also don’t need to be afraid that voting for their top choice could lead to their least favorite choice getting elected. If you were a voter who did not want to see Andrew Cuomo become governor, you didn’t need to spend hours agonizing about how others might vote: you just vote for multiple progressive candidates and leave Cuomo off your ballot. 

A jungle primary, by contrast, is what Andrew Cuomo wanted to jerry-rig New York’s election system into. After losing the primary, he insisted on staying in the election, and he wanted to force out other candidates in order to form a cross-party conservative coalition, backed by a lot of money and a lot of racism. Cuomo was able to strong-arm Mayor Eric Adams out of the general election, but failed to convince Republican candidate Curtis Silwa out. Nonetheless, Cuomo still got 73% of Republican voters to vote for him, according to exit polls. With Mamdani pulling 50.78% of the vote in the general election, one can easily see how Cuomo’s theory of the election could have worked if he bullied his way into a two-party race. Democracy and the City of New York would have been worse for it. 

Just Say No

Question 3 is shaping up to be a ā€œWhose side are you on?ā€ question. On the yes side: private equity, venture capitalists, and investment bankers. On the no side: every major labor union and progressive group in the state. 

The yes side, bankrolled by those who have been fighting for years to make working people’s lives worse, and the no side, backed by those who have been fighting to make working people’s lives better. The choice is clear: NO on Question 3. 

Jonathan Cohn is a member of Boston DSA and Policy Director for Progressive Massachusetts, a multi-issue grassroots organization that advocates for state level policy. He has been active in campaigns to expand voting rights, strengthen immigrants’ rights, increase education funding, and make a fairer tax code, among many more. He has also been a volunteer, neighborhood team leader, regional coordinator, or campaign manager for various candidate campaigns and ballot initiatives at the city, state, county, and national level.

PM in the News: “Question 9 Is a Referendum on a Multifaceted 2024 Gun Law”

Parker Mumford, “Question 9 Is a Referendum on a Multifaceted 2024 Gun Law,” Provincetown Independent, October 14, 2026.

ā€œYou can’t really address a problem you’re not collecting data on,ā€ Jon Cohn, the policy director for Progressive Massachusetts, told the Independent. ā€œThere’s nothing in the law that restricts someone’s legal gun ownership; it just makes guns easier to track.ā€

Cohn said the law’s broader ban on ā€œassault-style firearmsā€ is important to keep Massachusetts laws ā€œaligned with the type of weapons that exist in 2026.ā€

Cohn said that the bill’s expansion of red flag laws was important to protect against suicide, which ā€œis often forgotten about as a large share of gun violence.ā€

In 2024, about two-thirds of gun-related deaths in Massachusetts were suicides, according to the CDC.

ā€œIt was a very well thought out, robust piece of legislation responding to real needs,ā€ Cohn said.

…….

Cohn, meanwhile, said that repealing the law would set a bad precedent for gun control elsewhere in the country.

ā€œMassachusetts, as one of the more liberal states, should be constantly leading on policy,ā€ he said. ā€œIf we’re going backward on policy, it sets a really bad precedent for what can happen in other states.ā€

Look Who’s Spending

Look Who’s Spending

When it comes to ballot questions, it’s always incredibly revealing to look at who is spending, especially who’s spending big.

Who is bankrolling Question 3?

Question 3, which would change MA’s primary system to a California-style jungle primary, eliminate primaries for Lt. Governor, and allow SuperPACs to get their endorsements on your ballot, is largely bankrolled by private equity.

According to OCPF filings, 20 donors gave $100,000 more more, together $5.36 million (81% of individual money). One private investment firm gave $200,000.

And 23 private equity executives gave $4.7 million (71% of all money from individuals), with most of that from current or former executives at Bain Capital or Berkshire Partners. Remember: The most dangerous words in the English language are we’re from private equity, and we’re here to help.

Why do they care so much? Because California’s system has helped corporate interest groups elect more corporate-aligned Democrats to the California Legislature, and pushing up the cost and time of an election shuts out working-class candidates from even thinking of running in the first place. Private equity executives don’t put up this much money without expecting a return.

Who is bankrolling Question 5?

Question 5, which would impose a tighter revenue limit on the state and lead to cuts to essential services we all depend on, is mostly funded by the Massachusetts Opportunity Alliance, a dark money group created by CEOs after the Fair Share fight in 2022.

These CEOs were mad about the passage of the Fair Share Amendment (or “millionaire’s tax”), and they felt that CEOs weren’t willing to donate publicly against Fair Share. Their solution? Creating a vehicle for CEOs to donate privately for campaigns in the future.

As we face $3 billion in federal cuts next year, these CEOs want to kneecap our state’s ability to respond, and they want to undermine the Fair Share Amendment and prevent our state from doing more in housing, health care, education, transportation, and the environment (and make it harder to even do what we’re already doing).

Who is bankrolling Question 8?

Question 8, which would roll back the legalization of recreational marijuana, is almost entirely funded by an out-of-state dark money group called Smart Approaches to Marijuana (SAM) Action.

This group was founded by former Congressman Patrick Kennedy and former George W. Bush speechwriters David Sabet and David Frum (you might know him from his column in The Atlantic).

SAM, as a dark money group, doesn’t disclose its donors, but it has often been alleged to be funded by the liquor industry and the pharmaceutical industry, especially because whenever donors of anti-cannabis campaigns are disclosed, these are the big spenders. They don’t care about public health: they just don’t like competition.

Who is bankrolling No on 9?

Question 9 is different from the other 8 ballot questions. The other 8 were part on the ballot by the people who want you to vote yes. Question 9 was put on the ballot by the people who want you to vote No (it’s a “veto referendum” as opposed to a “ballot initiative petition”).

A Yes on 9 upholds the state’s 2024 gun safety law, which did important things like cracking down on ghost guns, updating our assault weapons ban, improving data collection on gun violence, and much more. But after Gov. Healey signed the bill, the Gun Owners Action League got to work to try to repeal it.

Who’s the biggest donor behind this repeal effort? None other than Smith & Wesson, whose $50K donation is 10% of the total.

Editorial: “Rather than a defense of their productivity, the Legislature’s reliance on omnibus bills should be an indictment”

Jonathan Cohn, “Rather than a defense of their productivity, the Legislature’s reliance on omnibus bills should be an indictment,” CommonWealth Beacon, October 13, 2026.

IN A RECENT piece for CommonWealth Beacon, Massachusetts Senate counsel James DiTullio defends the Legislature’s productivity against statistics that show Beacon Hill passing far fewer bills than other states. He points out that Massachusetts is one of just seven states that allow omnibus bills covering multiple issues, a structure that he says reduces the number of bills in comparison to the vast majority of states, which only permit single-issue legislation.

But his piece ignores the way that such statistics can be artificially padded at the same time that they are artificially limited in comparison to other states, and raises questions about the way that Beacon Hill’s lawmaking norms evade transparency and accountability.

Given our paternalistic home rule system, in which Beacon Hill acts as a gatekeeper for cities and towns seeking to pass their own laws, many of the bills signed into law end up being home rule petitions. The first bill signed into law this year was approving a charter change for Malden, and the most recent was about Natick’s deputy police chief. Why does Beacon Hill need a role in either?

The total count is also bloated by administrative matters like sick leave banks, in which state employees are able to benefit from unused sick leave from their colleagues.

Last year, for example, there were 20 sick leave banks and 61 home rule petitions signed into law out of a total of 101 new laws. Of the 231 bills signed into law this year, 200 were home rule petitions and 6 are sick leave banks. If we were to look at laws of statewide import, the national statistics DiTullio rails against would be even worse.

But DiTullio is correct that the Massachusetts General Court’s embrace of omnibus bills and policymaking through budgets and supplemental budgets makes simple bill tallies an imperfect yardstick. It was through last year’s budget, for instance, that Beacon Hill passed a new immigrant legal defense fund and banned tenant-paid broker’s fees, both significant wins. Bills can also be subsumed into thematic omnibus bills— say, for example, the PROTECT Act, which combined a number of important provisions from other standalone bills.

However, you would never know this from the Legislature’s website. It records many of those individual bills as dead for the session, to be mourned today and to rise like a phoenix from the ashes in January. Indeed, understanding which bills have become law in the Legislature through budgets and omnibuses requires expensive paid subscriptions to companies specializing in bill tracking. Pity the poor engaged constituent, or even legislator, simply trying to understand what’s going on.

………..