Skip to content

Testimony on the Joint Rules

November 17, 2026

Chair Galvin, Chair Lovely, and Members of the Joint Committee on Rules: 

My name is Jonathan Cohn, and I am the Policy Director at Progressive Massachusetts, a statewide grassroots advocacy group fighting for a more equitable, just, sustainable, and democratic commonwealth.

Thank you so much for holding today’s hearing on the Joint Rules.

Last summer, the Legislature did something significant: adopt a new set of Joint Rules for the first time in several sessions and respond to the grassroots calls for a more transparent and accountable legislative process. These new rules included public committee votes, longer notice for hearings, and accessible bill summaries–all of which help both rank-and-file legislators and members of the public to better participate. Activists had been asking for such measures for years, and you listened. 

However, to truly reap the benefits of these new rules, they must be followed. According to the independent Beacon Hill Tracker website, the compliance rate with such changes is about 50/50. The case of public committee votes is illustrative. Committee votes can appear in several different places depending on the committee, they can be posted months after the vote was taken, and sometimes, they do not appear at all. 

On the House side, committees are able to run out the clock on bills with no vote at all, with pocket study orders that undermine the promised transparency. 

Not all of the reforms in the new Joint Rules are worth celebrating, though, and we are seeing the negative consequences of one change very clearly now: the weakening of the July 31 deadline for the formal legislative session (Joint Rule 12A). 

By allowing conference committees to continue business well past July 31 as standard operating procedure, all that resulted was moving the July 31 deadline to January 5 (the last day of the session). There are now 12 conference committees still in the midst of negotiations, with one more soon likely given the recent supplemental budgets passed. 

Given that only 21 standalone policy bills have been signed into law this session so far, this represents a major share of the legislative output of the session, being decided after the election, in a busy holiday season, and when fewer people inside or outside the State House are actively engaged. I doubt any of you or your staff actually want to be negotiating final bill language in November, December, and perhaps even January. We urge you to restore the July 31 deadline as both a rule and a norm. Your lives, our lives, and the lives of everyone in the Commonwealth who can benefit from good policy would be better. 

We would urge a few other reforms as you revisit the Rules again in the next session: 

  • Disincentives, through rules and norms, for bulk study orders that take away individual attention and individual accountability for bills 
  • Clear explanation of changes to bills as they are amended during the legislative process, as the California Legislature’s website does through a built-in “Track Changes” versions function 
  • A reform (on the House side) of the Consolidated Amendment process, which is confusing for everyday people to follow and creates a lack of clarity around both process and outcomes 
  • Providing speaker order at every committee hearing so that testifiers have a clear sense of when they will attend. Hearings can last as long as eight hours, and most people cannot commit to being there for a full day and should not have to. Providing speaker order will empower more people to participate and show them more respect when they do.
  • Open Conference Committee meetings that contain actual discussion and debate over differences and priorities, as well as minutes or meeting logs of Conference Committees to track progress 

These changes all help engage both the public and legislators themselves more in the work of policymaking, delivering on the transparency and accountability that voters have repeatedly shown a hunger for and that can help lead to better policy outcomes. 

Thank you again for holding today’s hearing and for your consideration. 

Sincerely, 

Jonathan Cohn

Policy Director 

Progressive Massachusetts

Facebook
Twitter