Students Are More Than Just a Test Score

ThriveAct graphic

Testimony from Solidarity Lowell member Dee Halzack

Chair Lewis, Chair Garlick, and Members of the Joint Committee on Education:

I am writing today to urge you to give a favorable report to H.495 and S.246: An act empowering students and schools to thrive (“the Thrive Act”). 

Local students, parents, educators, and communities are the ones best able to determine what our local schools need, and how to measure student success.

State takeover of public schools and the graduation requirement based on the MCAS standardized test are both failing students and disrupting their education. These top-down, harmful educational policies are increasing racial inequities in our schools, rather than fixing them. We have seen, both through data and through student experiences, that state takeovers and high-stakes testing do not produce the long-term gains in student performance promised, and instead, they limit voice and narrow curricula.  In many cases poor performance had more to do with lack of resources than with poor administration or teaching. Educators complain about being forced to teach to the tests without regard for individual student needs or the characteristics of the community. Standardized testing does a disservice to students with special needs, including both the disabled and English language learners. 

While I myself am a native speaker of English, with decent writing skills, I have seen the damage done in testing situations to English language learners.  The stress of taking a test that determines whether or not you graduate, regardless of what your grades have been and how well you know what you studied, can make even a fluent English language learner freeze up or go so slow that they can’t finish the test in time. It happened to a friend of mine in COLLEGE. How much worse for younger students with less years of experience with the testing AND the language. 

I used to work for an educational publisher. I am familiar with the writings on inequity in educational testing and how hard it is to completely avoid.  Some students can be smart and yet so test-phobic that it affects their performance on a test negatively. While tests are a tool for assessing students, they are not the only tool and should not be used to make or break a student’s graduation. 

The Thrive Act creates a better system that focuses on supporting the whole child by focusing on the tools and resources schools need to thrive and by re-examining our approach to student assessment so that it can be more equitable, more accurate, and more holistic.  

Thank you for all your work on the hearing. Again, I urge you to swiftly advance H.495 and S.246: An act empowering students and schools to thrive.  

“Getting access to different languages should not be one of the problems to face.”

MassSpeaks

Testimony in support of the Mass Speaks Bill from Solidarity Lowell member Tara Hong

Dear Chairman Collins, Chairman Cabral, and Members of the Committee,   

My name is Tara Hong and I respectfully submits the following letter in support of S.1990/H.3084, An Act Relative to Language Access and Inclusion, and strongly urges the Joint Committee on State Administration and Regulatory Oversight to report the bill favorably.   

Nearly one in ten Massachusetts residents is limited English proficient. But as the COVID-19 pandemic made especially clear, many of our state agencies provide essential services and information only in English – effectively denying hundreds of thousands of families access to urgently-needed resources that can help them weather economic emergencies, care for their children, address health problems, stay housed, and much more. The Language Access and Inclusion Act would standardize and enforce language access protocols and practices at public-facing state agencies, ensuring non-English speaking residents can meet their basic needs and fully participate in their communities.

As an immigrant from Cambodia 10 years ago, English is my second language. It was tough for me personally for almost six years of my life learning English just to want to communicate in the community, pass tests, and or ask for support in the community. However, one good thing about my city is its diversity. I was surrounded by many people who spoke my language and were able to help me around. That is why I am writing to you today to ask for your support for this bill. I believe that everyone, no matter where they come from or what they speak, everyone should not be unable to ask for help and support because they don’t speak English. As an immigrant country and an immigrant state with many backgrounds all around, getting access to different languages should not be one of the problems to face. 

Everyone must have equal access to our government, no matter what language they speak. As Massachusetts is one of the most linguistically diverse states in the nation, we strongly urge you to issue a favorable report for An Act Relative to Language Access and Inclusion.  

Respectfully Submitted,   

Tara Hong

PM in the News: “We Don’t Have the Money” Doesn’t Cut It

Chris Lisinski, “Healey, not Baker, gets to sign big tax relief law,” State House News Service, October 4, 2023.

“Voices on the left were also less enthused about the final product. The Progressive Massachusetts group contrasted the $1 billion in relief with the roughly similar amount of revenue the state expects to generate this year from a new surtax on high earners, revenue from which will be earmarked for education and transportation investments.

“It is simply not acceptable for legislators to say ‘We don’t have the money’ when it comes to meeting basic needs, when they are willing to spend hundreds of millions of dollars on unnecessary and regressive tax cuts for the rich and large corporations,” the group said in an unsigned statement. “Our commonwealth has the resources we need to solve the great challenges we face; the question is whether our elected officials have the will to do so.” “

Show Your Support for Public Education by Showing up for the Thrive Act Next Week

Sign up to let us know that you’re joining us for the Thrive Act hearing on October 4th!

Location: Gardner Auditorium

Time: 2pm – 8pm


The Thrive Act (H.495/S.246) would end the state’s ineffective approach to educational assessment and improvement by:

  1. Replacing the undemocratic and ineffective state takeover of local public schools with actual improvement plans and processes
  2. Replacing the (mis)use of MCAS as a graduation requirement with graduation based on successful completion of coursework that meets state standards and frameworks
  3. Establishing a commission to create an authentic, whole-child system for assessment and accountability.

The state has a responsibility to help all students and schools succeed, but, even by their own measures, the state’s interventions have not worked. It’s time to replace top-down ineffective punitive approaches with approaches that build local capacity, address root causes, and truly help students thrive.

In addition to showing up, here’s how you can help:

  1. Testify in person or virtually! Share your story about why this is important to you. Sign up to testify here! (deadline: October 3rd at 3 pm)
  2. Submit written testimony! Use this tool to craft your own testimony to send to the Education Committee.
  3. Help us spread the message about the hearing!

Testimony to the Joint Committee on the Judiciary in support of “An Act supporting consenting young adults” (H.1617/S.1110)

Progressive Mass recently signed on to testimony from the Massachusetts Coalition for Juvenile Justice Reform in support of H.1617/S.1110: An Act supporting consenting young adults.

Read an excerpt below and read the full coalition testimony here.

This legislation is an effort to come into line with a majority of states, to recognize that young people have consensual sexual contact with one another and criminalizing that contact is not the best way to respond to it. It is an issue for families, faith communities, and public health officials, rather than law enforcement….

If the goal is to delay teen sexual activity and ensure young people are in healthy relationships – both physically and emotionally – the law actually has built a barrier between teens and trusted adults who can talk to them and advise them on making healthy decisions and identifying and staying away from unhealthy relationships.

News Roundup – August 30, 2023

Alison Kuznitz, “Student hails new free community college program as ‘life-changing,'” State House News Service, August 24, 2023.

“I got called and was told that I was eligible for this program, which is going to be life-changing for me,” said Mends, who attended Needham Public Schools, at a press conference in Wellesley. “It’s been a long road and to have this financial burden lifted is amazing. And I’m excited for the opportunities that are going to open up and the things that are going to change my family.”

New program will allow undocumented students in Massachusetts to get in-state tuition rates,” CBS News, August 22, 2023.

“This is a big step forward for students who have been growing up here, learning here, living here, working hard here, following their dreams right here in Massachusetts,” Healey said a press conference Tuesday. “It’s nothing more than what is fair and what is right. They’re going to be able to continue their journey on the same terms as their peers in a place that is their home.”

Matt Stout, “Massachusetts to change how Asian, Black, and other populations are counted in ‘most expansive’ effort in country,” Boston Globe, August 21, 2023.

“If we’re able to break down that data, we can target messages better, we can understand where there are disparities in health, disparities in education,” said Gary Chu, chairperson of the state’s Asian American & Pacific Islanders Commission. “No group is a monolith.”

Ayana Archie, “A 4% income tax on millionaires will make lunch free for Massachusetts K-12 students,” NPR, August 18, 2023.

“Massachusetts’ new budget will provide free school lunches for K-12 students, thanks to an additional 4% income tax on state residents’ incomes above $1 million….The extra tax, known as the Fair Share Amendment, was approved by voters in November 2022. It is generating an extra $1 billion for the state. Of that, $224 million will go to K-12 programs, including free lunch and implementing “clean energy” in schools, the governor’s office said.”

Andrew Brinker, “State may deny grants to communities that don’t comply with new MBTA housing law,” Boston Globe, August 17, 2023.

“The new rules threaten towns that avoid rezoning under the new law with losing out on more than a dozen state grant programs, which combined provide tens of millions of dollars to communities for an array of local planning and development programs. That’s on top of two major programs — MassWorks and Housing Choice — from which state officials could already withhold money, as well as the threat of legal action from community groups and the attorney general.”

Christian MilNeil, “A More Generous State Budget Means Better Service Is Coming to Regional Transit Authorities,” StreetsBlog Mass, August 16, 2023.

“But in the meantime, the RTA administrators we spoke with say they’ll likely use the funding to expand their service hours into evenings and weekends, and to expand fare-free programs, which heretofore have relied on dwindling federal pandemic relief funds.

Emily Piper-Vallillo, “‘Food is the biggest expense’: Mass. families welcome permanent free school meals for students,” WBUR, August 15, 2023.

Right now 26% of families with children in Massachusetts are food insecure. And when you take a look across those families, one in four of them don’t qualify for free or reduced pricing meals,” she said. “They make too much, but they’re still struggling to put food on the table.”

Taylor Dolven, “Massachusetts’ goal to reduce driving lags behind other states,” Boston Globe, August 13, 2023.

“Massachusetts is aiming to reduce the number of miles driven per household by just 3 percent from 2015 to 2030 as part of its climate plan, according to figures provided by the Executive Office of Energy and Environmental Affairs. Minnesota, by contrast, is aiming to reduce vehicle miles traveled per person by 7 percent in that time frame. In Colorado, the goal is 8 percent. In Washington, the goal is around 16 percent. And in California, the goal is 20 percent.”

Margaret Monsell, “Maybe the Globe should take a look at itself,” CommonWealth, August 5, 2023.

“But this recent Globe trip on the Wayback Machine suggests a possibility that its editorial melancholy about our degraded legislative democracy hasn’t yet considered: Has the downsized State House coverage by the Globe itself helped to bring about this lamentable state of affairs?”

Marcela García, “The simple card that’s changing undocumented immigrants’ lives,” Boston Globe, July 31, 2023.

“People like Mayra and her cousin know very well that a driver’s license is issued for public safety purposes only. But the card exemplifies other intangibles for them: relief, gratitude, hope, a sense of belonging — and the feeling ofbeing a little less invisible to the rest of Massachusetts.”

Nik DeCosta-Klipa, “What is — and isn’t — in the (again-late) Mass. budget deal,” WBUR, July 31, 2023.

What’s in it: The massive spending bill includes some big policy changes. Here are the ones that made the final cut.

Ashley Nellis, “It’s time to end eternal punishment for young adults,” CommonWealth, July 27, 2023.

“The racial dynamics at play in extreme sentences cannot be overlooked. The Sentencing Project’s study finds that a shocking two thirds of young people sentenced to LWOP are Black (including Semedo). At the time of his crime, the media was blatantly contributing to racist portrayals of Black people through racially charged descriptors like savage, animalistic, and superpredator. These misrepresentations of Black people have surely contributed to the high representation of them in our prisons, especially when we look at those with the harshest penalties.”

Sen. Pat Jehlen, “Some thoughts on where we need to be competitive,” CommonWealth, July 26, 2023.

“Some urge us to reduce the tax on short term capital gain, but 80 percent of the benefits would go to the top 1 percent, widening the income gap. It would contribute nothing to economic growth. It would cost $130 million a year that can’t be spent on housing, childcare, transit, childcare, and other things that would help businesses, families, and competitiveness.”

Editorial Board, “Free prison calls provide a lifeline for inmates, families,” Boston Globe, July 25, 2023.

“Keeping those who are incarcerated connected to their families is one of the simplest ways to encourage rehabilitation and, therefore, enhance public safety. This tiny bit of progress is already a year overdue. It shouldn’t have to wait any longer.”

Margaret McKenna, “Our state hasn’t achieved anything resembling educational equity,” Boston Globe, July 17, 2023.

“The basic principle in the 1993 Education Reform was that all students should be educated to meet high standards and that progress should be measured. In order to achieve that, we need to recognize that students come from different environments, have different learning styles and needs. Treating all students equally does not produce equity. Students are much more than what is measured with a group of narrow subject matter tests.”

Take Action for Healthy Youth

Across the country — and unfortunately, here in Massachusetts — we are seeing right-wing advocates mobilizing on behalf of narrowing school curricula, banning books, and erasing the experiences of LGBTQ youth.

That’s why we were happy when Governor Healey took a step to move Massachusetts in the opposite direction–that of inclusion.

It may come as a shock, but the sex ed curriculum framework for schools here in Massachusetts was last updated in 1999.

Healey’s proposed updated curriculum framework reflects the Healthy Youth Act in requiring that sex ed is comprehensive, medically accurate, age-appropriate, consent-based, and inclusive — as it should be, and as it should have been a generation ago.

The Board of Elementary and Secondary Education (BESE) is soliciting public comment on this new draft comprehensive health and physical education curriculum framework through Monday, August 28.

Can we count on you to join us in submitting supportive comments by the 28th? Can you think of 5 friends, family,colleagues or neighbors who care about kids getting the comprehensive education they need to make smart and healthy choices? Can you ask them to join us? This is how the opposition is gathering comments and we need to meet this challenge.

You can find the Healthy Youth Coalition’s toolkit and a sample template below. In solidarity,

Submit public comments in support of the new draft MA Comprehensive Health and Physical Education Curriculum Framework

You can submit public comment one of three ways:

  1. Submit using the Public Comment Survey: https://survey.alchemer.com/s3/6646350/Comprehensive-Health-and-Physical-Education-Framework-Public-Comment
  2. Email to Kristen McKinnon at chpef@mass.gov
  3. Mail to the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education, Attention: Kristen McKinnon, 75 Pleasant Street, Malden, MA 0213

How to Write a Comment:

The Healthy Youth Coalition has helpful guide for submitting public comment, with talking points here.

Here’s a sample for you to use if you want to get started:

I am writing today in full support of the new comprehensive health and physical education curriculum framework. Having an updated framework that is grounded in science and reflects best practices will help health educators teach students what they need to know at every grade level.

It is especially important that students have a health curriculum that emphasizes the importance of consent to healthy relationships and one that is inclusive of students of all gender identities and sexual orientations.

I urge BESE to vote to adopt this new Framework and I look forward to learning how DESE will support educators to implement it in their classrooms.

Passing the Prison Moratorium and Ending Life without Parole Go Hand in Hand

Prison

Massachusetts Judiciary Joint Committee

Testimony for S.1979/H.1795 and An Act to Reduce Mass Incarceration, (S.1045 / H.1821),

Caroline Bays, Watertown Massachusetts

Dear Chairs Eldridge and Day,

Thank you for hearing my testimony today on S.1979 / H.1795, an act that would establish a five-year moratorium on building new prisons. 

I am usually before you as a Watertown city councilor or as a board member on behalf of Progressive Massachusetts. But today I  am here on behalf of my dear friend who has spent the last 16 of his 35 years in prison. 

Six years ago, I had a life-changing event when I was asked to visit this young man who was experiencing a mental health crisis. As a result, I have seen up close how dysfunctional, counter-productive, and destructive prisons are to the human beings who live within those walls. 

Prisons no longer even pay lip service to rehabilitation; they are designed purely for punishment. They no longer try to help people get back on their feet and become productive members of our society. The stories I have heard–the danger, harm, cruelty, and viciousness he has experienced are destructive not just to him but to our society and who we are as a state. 

Prisons as they are currently structured do not make us safer–they make us less safe. And we are harming the most vulnerable members of our society–people who need help. We are putting people who are mentally ill in prison; we are putting people who are addicted to drugs in prison; we are putting people who are experiencing dire poverty in prison. 

Since when did we decide that it was morally right to treat those who need our help as criminals and deny them the support and treatment they need? Whom does it help? This is cruel to those impacted and actually decreases our safety. 

In addition I also ask you to support An Act to Reduce Mass Incarceration (S.1045 / H.1821). These bills go hand in hand because ending life without parole and the imprisonment of people who committed crimes when they were teenagers not only counters everything we know about human development, it unnecessarily imprisons people who are perfectly safe to release back into the community. In addition these sentences are disproportionately imposed on people of color.  Please pass these necessary next steps in order to create a more just and equitable society.

I urge you to help us look for solutions that will benefit everyone–the incarcerated people and the general public. We have an opportunity to truly change how our society manages public safety. The creation of prisons has not only failed to end crime, by disconnecting people from their families, education, jobs and societal support, mass incarceration has actually been responsible for an increase in criminal infractions. Let’s be the state that shows how to end this cycle of incarceration and create solutions that really do lead to healing – of individuals and our community.  Thank you for your time.

📣Take Action in Support of No Cost Calls & the Prison Moratorium

Last year, after impressive organizing work from impacted communities, the MA Legislature passed No Cost Calls and the Prison Moratorium.

But neither became law because of our former Republican governor, Charlie Baker, who vetoed them at the end of the session.

We now have a new session, a new governor, and a new opportunity to complete these wins.

Earlier today, the Judiciary Committee on Beacon Hill held testimony on both of these and other bills. The case for both is still clear.

We know that we cannot incarcerate our way to public safety, and that investing in communities, not new prisons, helps communities to thrive.

And we know that keeping families connected, by ending the practice of charging predatory fees for phone calls to loved ones behind bars, is good for public safety and economic security.

And Beacon Hill knew both of these last year when they passed such legislation. Both chambers also recognized the importance of No Cost Calls when they included similar language in their FY 2024 budgets, still stuck in negotiations.

We shouldn’t have to wait until July of next year to finish these victories.

Can you email the State Legislature in support of No Cost Calls and the Prison Moratorium?

“The perils of one-party rule”

Kelly Garrity, “The perils of one-party rule,” POLITICO, July 24, 2023.

“There’s a sense of complacency in the Massachusetts Legislature,” Jonathan Cohn, political director for Progressive Massachusetts, told Playbook. “When you have a situation where most of them never face any type of electoral challenge — primary or general — if you don’t finish something, you can get the band back together in the next legislative session.”